There is no substitute for hands-on experience, and this is especially true for sommeliers whose business it is to know the wines they serve inside and out. Working a stage, or harvest internship, is a unique opportunity for somms to interact with the product they sell on the floor. Talking to guests about the soil type of a vineyard is nice, but having had that soil under your fingernails is a far more powerful testament to your experience. Taking time out to do a stage also helps somms develop a more nuanced understanding of winemaking processes and a deeper appreciation for the level of work—and labor of love—that goes into making wine.
Producers often host sommeliers or other aspiring winemakers for parts of the harvest and crush season. This can be a day or two of fun, engaging work. It can also be four to six weeks of hard, intense labor. Like a restaurant stage, most of the compensation consists of knowledge and experience. To mark the end of harvest season in the Northern Hemisphere, SevenFifty Daily spoke with three somms who this year made the effort to take time off from the floor to participate in harvest work. We share their discoveries here.
Setting Up the Internship
“I literally cornered him,” says sommelier Max Coane of meeting with Pierre-Yves Colin at an event in San Francisco. “I told him I was going to work harvest with him, and it turns out he was cool with it.” That’s what it took for Coane to get a coveted spot on the harvest team at Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey, one of the most revered domaines in Burgundy. Coane was able to express to the winemaker his love for the domaine’s wine—and for the region—in an enthusiastic way that was both friendly and direct.
Don’t miss the latest drinks industry news and insights. Sign up for our award-winning Daily Dispatch newsletter—delivered to your inbox every week.
But anyone choosing to work harvest should keep in mind that it’s hard work. It’s a lot to ask of the producer who’ll be hosting you, too, as you’ll need to be trained on the spot for every task, so it’s important to apply yourself and perform your duties earnestly. You’re committing to at least one week at the winery, if not three to five weeks or more. You’re going to spend that time away from your job, and you may also need to make certain sacrifices, such as taking a pay cut for the duration of the stage. But for some sommeliers, the backbreaking work of turning grapes into finished wine is invaluable. “Harvest is hard,” says Robert Gomez, a lead server and bartender at Saffron in Walla Walla, Washington, “but it’s highly rewarding work. To me, there’s no better way to gain an understanding of wine than to make some.”
For Coane, who was working as the head sommelier at Saison in San Francisco at the time, the decision on where to do harvest was easy. “We have a big collection of [Pierre-Yves Colin’s] wines at Saison,” he says, “and have been supporting him ever since he was splitting his time between his father’s domaine and his own.”
Nicolas Capron-Manieux reflects on his stage at Domaine Hubert Lamy—and its test of his endurance
The wines sommeliers choose to represent on their wine lists can help pave the way for opportunities to work harvest at wineries around the world, and this was true of Coane’s time in Burgundy during the 2018 harvest. Coane also says that Colin told him he thought it would be a good idea to bring on someone who already represents his wines—he felt that bringing an American stagiaire to Burgundy would result in a stateside ambassador who could promote his wines as well as help people understand the domaine. Coane no longer works at Saison, but he continues to represent Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey’s wines as the wine director at Prime Cellar, an online rare-wine retailer.
Creating Work-Work Balance During Harvest
Wendy Shoemaker, the head sommelier at Californios in San Francisco, found her harvest opportunity during an annual somm retreat at Peay Vineyards in Annapolis, California. “The Peays do an annual lovefest for somms,” she says, “which includes camping in the vineyards, tasting library wines, and spending time [among] the vines.” During the retreat in 2018 she talked with the winegrower and vineyard manager, Nick Peay, about the possibility of working harvest and wound up with a few weeks of work at the winery—and a guesthouse to stay in while she was there.
Shoemaker’s harvest internship was done in intervals. She spent one week at the winery, mostly harvest, then a week back in the city at Californios, then went back to Peay for a week of winery work. “My employers are people who respect the sommelier side of things,” she says. “My boss is a sommelier as well, and she wanted to be supportive of what I’m doing. That was why I did the split timing—one week on, one week back. I was able to set everything up to run while I was gone … It wasn’t exactly easy, but I was happy we set it up.”
For Gomez, the decision to work harvest was made easier by the fact that Walla Walla’s restaurant community is surrounded by hundreds of wineries. He worked crush this year at Gramercy Cellars, near Saffron, and he was able to split his time between his duties at the winery and his bar and wine work at the restaurant.
Having the two jobs so close together made a big difference. “This is very much wine country, so both my restaurant [employers] and Brandon [Moss, the head winemaker at Gramercy] were understanding,” Gomez says. “A lot of the people I work with at the restaurant have worked harvest before.” While being able to maintain two jobs for a period can be convenient, it can also mean sacrificing a portion of your regular income, as well as your personal time—and sleep. Gomez’s harvest work included everything from taking vineyard samples to sorting fruit, barreling wine, racking, and doing punchdowns—and he attests that “90 percent of winemaking is cleaning.”
What made the biggest impression on Gomez was the way in which winemakers use their senses. “It’s all about palate,” he says. “Just as sommeliers use their palate, you develop that skill in the winery, too. It influences all the decisions you make.” But it’s a different way of using your palate, he points out, “because you have to taste wine that isn’t finished.” And the tasting continues all harvest long.
Coane, whose firsthand look at the Burgundy vineyard experience included picking grapes and receiving them in the winery, was surprised by the outside influences in Burgundy, even at a domaine as esteemed as Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey. “I found it very interesting,” he says, “that Pierre used to work for David Ramey at Stony Hill back in the ’90s. [Ramey] was the single biggest influence on Pierre’s winemaking. That blew my mind—that a Burgundian winemaker was claiming a U.S. winemaker as an influence.”
And whether it may seem somewhat glamorous from the outside, Shoemaker found that harvest life involves a lot of hard work and sweat. During her first week at Peay, she was helping to bring in 10 to 14 tons of fruit per day. She drove a forklift and did lots of equipment hookups and lifting, which she says required “significant physical strength.” Some of her mornings started at 5:30, when she went out to walk the rows and start harvesting. When I interviewed Gomez, he had just finished a shift of physically demanding manual punchdowns—and it was eight o’clock at night.
In addition, Coane found that his working understanding of French was particularly helpful during his stage. “It’s literally for practical use,” he says. “You don’t want to get smacked in the head by a tractor. You don’t want to get hurt because you couldn’t get out of the way if someone’s frantically yelling at you.”
Reflecting on the Harvest Experience
There are a number of things somms should consider before taking time off to do harvest. “There are two kinds of Americans who come to Burgundy,” says Coane. “There’s ones that go to eat at [the restaurant] Ma Cuisine, get drunk, and party. Then there’s ones that come to learn the vin Bourguignon and la vie Bourguignon. We shouldn’t just be studying the wine. We should be studying the people.” Harvest is not just about the products a region produces, it’s about the cultural context in which they exist. Burgundy is first and foremost a place with its own identity. Wine is one aspect of that identity, but understanding the larger setting is paramount to understanding the wine. For sommeliers, understanding just the wine from these places that are steeped in tradition is misguided. The harvest experience can connect you to the people, and to the larger story of the place itself.
Shoemaker, who has a master’s degree in chemistry, had her curiosity piqued even further. Her harvest work inspired her to make wine herself. “This should be more a part of what we do [as sommeliers],” she says. “We often wax poetic, saying, ‘You should let the wine make itself,’ but I left with a great respect for the science and technology involved in the process.”
For those on the fence about working a harvest, Gomez highly recommends finding an internship and doing it. “Find a producer you love, and let them know you’ll do whatever it takes, that you’re interested in learning,” he says. “It adds a layer of depth to your wine knowledge.” As a bonus, Gomez is getting course credit for his university enology program for the harvest he worked.
Coane’s harvest also left him with an awareness of a difference between the way sommeliers perceive wine and the way winemakers do—especially Burgundian winemakers. “Burgundy is their birthright,” he says. “To us, it’s a rarity. To them, it’s about family and history. When we look at the wine in the glass, we see dollar signs. When they look at it, they see ghosts.”
Jackson Rohrbaugh, MS, is a Seattle native who has a bachelor’s degree in creative writing from the University of Washington. He discovered a passion for wine while working at Canlis, and eventually became the lead sommelier. When not working nights on the floor, he loves hunting down bargains in wine shops, reading literary fiction, and cooking Korean BBQ. Follow him on Instagram.